Please bear in mind, I’m not a scientist, so this is just basic stuff I’ve learned as a plumber over the past 25 years. So as a plumber, I only know of 2 ways to prevent potable water from freezing: heat and motion.
First, if the freezing point of water is 32 degrees and you keep the water’s temperature above 32 degrees, using a heat source, it will not freeze. Many commercial backflow prevention assemblies are located inside of a climate controlled building, so freezing temperatures and theives don’t affect them. (***A quick note – insulation bags do not produce heat).
With over 25 years of backflow experience, we’ve seen numerous methods employed to try to prevent freeze damage to backflow prevention devices. Blankets taped around assemblies, boxes filled with insulation, newspapers and magazines wrapped around the assemblies. None of these methods worked.
We’ve also seen electric heat strips used, which actually worked, but we never recommend wrapping electrical wire around copper piping to avoid a potential electrical hazard. Nor do we recommend using electric heating pads, but we’ve seen it.
We’ve also seen electric space heaters and kerosene heaters used to try to protect backflow prevention assemblies from freezing. Again, because of the electrical hazard and fire hazard, we do not recommend these methods.
Most often we see insulation bags covering backflow prevention assemblies. But after 25 years, I can tell you that insulation bags will not prevent your backflow prevention assembly from freezing, especially if we fall below freezing for many hours or days. Using pipe insulation won’t prevent the piping to your assembly from freezing either.
Second, moving water tends not to freeze, especially in our environment where freezing temps don’t typically last for 24 hour periods for many days and weeks. So if the water is constantly moving through your backflow prevention assembly, it will not freeze.
So how do you keep water moving through a backflow prevention assembly?
Technically, you could go outside drain your irrigation system and turn on the number 2 test port (on a PVB) or the number 4 test port (on a DCVA or RP) to drip your backflow prevention assembly. But how many of us will actually do that every time it’s going to freeze?
I prefer something easier than having to mess with the test ports every time it freezes, such as a freeze protection valve.